The following article by Carlos Martinez marks two anniversaries falling days apart – the 105th of the Communist Party of China on 1 July and the 250th of the United States on 4 July – and asks what these two political projects have contributed to the world.
This article first appeared in the Morning Star.
This week features two anniversaries that, taken together, tell much of the story of our age. On 1 July, the Communist Party of China marked 105 years since its founding. On 4 July, the United States celebrates 250 years since the Declaration of Independence. The two milestones invite a comparison: what have these two political projects contributed to the world?
War and peace
The US was born in a revolution against empire and has spent much of its life building one. By one widely cited reckoning, the US has been at war for over 90 percent of its history – from the wars of continental conquest to Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Iran. It maintains around 800 military bases in 80 countries and spends over a trillion dollars a year on its armed forces.
China’s record could hardly be more different. It has not fought a war in close to five decades. The major conflicts it was previously drawn into – Korea and Vietnam – were in defence of neighbours resisting imperialism. It has never launched a war of aggression, never seized a colony, never carried out a regime-change operation, never imposed a unilateral sanctions regime. Its foreign policy still rests on the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence – mutual respect for sovereignty, non-aggression, non-interference, equality and mutual benefit – first articulated in 1954. Even on the nuclear question, where Western media warn of a Chinese build-up, China holds around 500 warheads to the United States’ several thousand, and remains the only major nuclear power consistently and unambiguously committed to a policy of no first use, in place since its first nuclear test in 1964.
This difference scales up to the level of the world system. The US sits at the head of an order it designed and polices – an order of dollar dominance, financial sanctions, military alliances, and the assumed right to intervene anywhere in defence of its own economic and strategic interests. As the New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman famously put it, “the hidden hand of the market will never work without a hidden fist – McDonald’s cannot flourish without McDonnell Douglas”.
China, by contrast, has thrown its weight behind a multipolar trajectory: the Belt and Road Initiative, to which three-quarters of UN member states have signed up; the expansion of BRICS; global initiatives on development, security, civilisational dialogue and governance; and an insistence on sovereign equality – that nations be free to choose their own path. One project seeks to preserve a hierarchy with a single power at the top. The other works towards a global community of shared future, in which all nations participate on equal terms.
Neoliberalism versus common prosperity
Over four decades China has lifted hundreds of millions of people out of poverty – more than three-quarters of the global total – and in 2021 declared the elimination of extreme poverty, a decade ahead of the UN’s own target. It has built the largest public medical insurance network on earth, covering essentially its entire population, extended pension coverage to all its elderly, and largely solved the problem of homelessness.
Continue reading The USA and the CPC – a tale of two anniversaries